Saturday, September 29, 2012
REVIEW: A Little Wanting Song by Cath Crowley
A Little Wanting Song is told in two narratives. The first is Charlie Duskin, a musician who sings only for herself in darkened rooms. She's dealing with the loss of both her mother and her gran and the consequences of these losses has made Charlie's father pull away from her entirely. What Charlie really wants is for her father to talk to her, take some notice of her. What makes things worse for Charlie, is that she doesn't really have anyone else is her life. She wants love and a boyfriend, but she also wants friendship - an emotional connection with somebody, anybody.
And then there's Rose. She lives next door to Charlie's grandparents, but Charlie and Rose have never been friends. Rose has her boyfriend Luke and another friend, Dave Robbie and a fairly good life in the country. But Rose wants more. She wants to live in the city and go to a private school and have more in her life than her mother has had. She doesn't want to end up pregnant and be forced into a job that doesn't challenge her. And Rose believes that the only way to do this is by befriending Charlie Duskin in the hopes that when Charlie's family leaves for the summer back to Melbourne, Rose will be with them.
I really loved this story. Both girls have such strong feelings of longing that it's hard not to become emotionally involved in both of their stories. I found myself more connected to Charlie's story. I could really relate to the way in which Charlie holds herself away from people and instead watches from afar. She seems to hide within her music and she holds onto her Gran and to her mother by continuing to speak to them long after they've been truly gone. I found it heartbreaking the way in which Charlie's father barely speaks to her or acknowledges her presence. I really liked Charlie's relationship with her grandfather and also how she seemed to grow in confidence over the course of the novel. Some of Charlie's insights into herself, her family and life around her are so beautiful.
And Rose. I really just wanted her to be a little more open with the truth when it came to befriending Charlie. She's got a bit of an attitude and she's said some mean things about Charlie over the years, but it was still nice to see how much Rose changes too. She has to be held a bit accountable for the 'Charlie Dorkin' song and there's plenty of ups and downs in her relationships Luke and Robbie. I liked that she's a girl interested in science and can also see how lucky she is and how much she has by the end.
This is such a beautiful book and I don't feel as though I can do it justice in this review! I highly recommend that you pick up this book and discover its beauty for yourself.
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Oh, I definitely have to hunt this one down! I really enjoyed Graffiti Moon and I love books where it's more about the complexities of friendship. Thanks for highlighting this one fir me!ReplyDelete
You're very welcome, Anna! I loved this one and I hope you do as well :)Delete
I love this book so much! Thank you for your brilliant review.ReplyDelete
I really loved it too :)Delete
I really enjoyed Graffiti Moon so I've been after this books for ages. I'm glad it lived up to GM!ReplyDelete
Different storyline, same beautiful writing style :)Delete
I loved Graffiti Moon and your review for this has made me need this one! Thanks for sharing :)ReplyDelete
You're very welcome, Raimy! Happy to share the excitement for some wonderful books like this :)Delete